Michigan lost to Oregon this week. I wasn’t expecting the Wolverines to win, not after Oregon beat up on aO$U. The Ducks were favored by 10 ½ points, anyway.
I missed the game because I was at the NSU-Western Alabama game with my daughters. One of their sororities was having a Dads Day, and there was food. (NSU won handily.)
Michigan didn’t even beat the spread.
We only managed 71 yards in the air with two quarterbacks who are supposed to be way better than they’ve shown us. To refresh everyone’s memories: Bryce Underwood was a 5-star recruit and the subject of a pretty ridiculous NIL bidding war. Ann Arbor erupted in celebration when he flipped from LSU to Michigan.

Then Sheronne Moore destroyed his career, taking Underwood down with him.
I say it that way because I think Moore was too distracted by his off-the-field antics to pay attention to what he was supposed to be doing, which was developing a multi-million-dollar college quarterback.
In his first season, Underwood threw 11 touchdowns – and nine interceptions.
His sophomore season, under new coach Kyle Whittingham, didn’t start out any better. In six games, he threw five TDs and 6 picks. He also fumbled three times in each season, losing two both times. He needed a good QB coach, and Moore ignored that. Whittingham apparently tried, but it doesn’t seem to have been good enough.
QB2 Tommy Carr did alright his first time out, eking out a win against Penn State. But he really wasn’t ready to take on full-time duties, I think. I’m pretty sure the plan was to let him take over after Underwood graduated (or likely got drafted).
Michigan is 5-4 this season, with UCLA and aO$U still to go. We need one more win to be bowl-eligible, and I’m not sure we can beat either of the two remaining opponents. UCLA is ranked 4th in the nation, is undefeated, and is favored by 5 points as I write this. We’ll be lucky if we stay that close.
The Ohio State game is a toss-up. They’re playing their freshman QB2 because they have to, losing Justin Sayin to a season-ending shoulder injury six games into the season. I’m almost glad I’m going to miss the game for Nutcracker rehearsals.
A lot of Michigan fans thought Kyle Whittingham was a great choice to replace Moore. He had a good record at Utah and brought a good coaching staff with him, including a QB coach to better develop that multi-million-dollar quarterback we had.
And I was willing to give him some grace. The players needed to learn the coaches’ culture, and the coaches needed to learn their players’ strengths, and that takes time. We’d just replaced 13 of the 14 coaches.
But I’m just not seeing any improvement anywhere along the line. Our kicking game stinks. Our quarterbacks aren’t making the throws they need to make, and the team has just looked listless. There doesn’t seem to be any fire in them, and that comes from—or doesn’t come from—the coaching staff. Whittingham looks lost on the sideline and sounds lost in the postgame interviews.
I think it’s time the powers that be in Ann Arbor admit they goofed in this hiring and prepare to move on. I wasn’t this hard on Harbaugh or Moore, but they didn’t look this bad. They made progress, even if they had problems.
The biggest issue with replacing Whittingham at this point is that it’s going to screw up our recruiting in a huge way.
That, and we don’t have an athletic director right now. Warde Manuel is resigning in December, thank goodness. But it’s hard to hire a head football coach at the same time you’re searching for a new AD. And the school’s new president hasn’t officially taken office yet.
We’re in a state of transition that’s going to set us back for a few years, unfortunately. I think it’s going to take at least five years before we’re really competitive again.
Go Blue.
Thanks for reading. Feel free to share a thought in the comments. Sign up for my infrequent newsletter here. Find some of my other writing at The Good Men Project, too. Subscribe to the blog via the link in the right sidebar or follow it on Mastodon. You can also add my RSS feed to your favorite reader.
Share your thoughts!